Decisions don't close, or nobody knows who decides
Start here
One decider, total backing
One named decider for a live operation, paired with visible, unconditional backing for the calls they make under pressure.
Try this first
Name one decider, and have leadership say in front of everyone that they will stand behind that person's calls.
Borrowed from NASA Mission Control, where the flight director has final authority during a mission. Flight director Gene Kranz is the best-known example. Read the original source.
Other moves for this problem (12 of 12)
Kind of change
- Red Lines and a Bridge · Each side names its limits and proposes a fixFor when: A team is stuck restating positions and going in circles.
- Walk the Roots · Talk to each person before the meetingFor when: A big AI-driven change is about to hit the room and quiet dissenters exist.
- Disagree, then commit · Argue first, then everyone backs the decisionFor when: Dissent turns into quiet sabotage after a decision.
- The revert and "rough consensus." · Make changes easy to undo, and decide by rough agreementFor when: Fear of mistakes is freezing action, or unanimity is being demanded.
- Lead by the Piece · Leadership rotates with the taskFor when: Leadership is fixed by title but the work needs different expertise from one task to the next.
- Quorum, not unanimity · Decide when enough people agreeFor when: Decisions stall waiting for full consensus, or drift.
- Vision and Run Are Different JobsFor when: The visionary is also (poorly) running the day-to-day, or the two roles are tangled.
- The Incident Command System · One person runs the response, whatever their rankFor when: Crises dissolve into confusion about who's in charge.
- Ringi — circulate the written proposal · Circulate a written proposal for sign-offFor when: Decisions land without shared ownership.
- Common Ground FirstFor when: Sessions burn their first half getting everyone to the same starting line.
- Dot votingFor when: Prioritization is being captured by the loudest or most senior voice.
- Sense of the meeting · Find a way forward everyone can stand behindFor when: A decision important enough that a defeated minority would quietly drag its feet.